A number of achievements in higher education of Vietnam over 30 years of renovation (1986-2016)
Abstract: In the cause of comprehensive renovation of Vietnam from 1986 until now, the Party
and State have implemented many guidelines, policies and measures to renovate and develop the
higher education. The higher education has been gradually integrating into and moving towards the
world’s conventional education model. Despite some remaining constraints and challenges, the
process of renovation of tertiary education system has gained important achievements and made
great contributions to the socio-economic development. This paper initially studies some
attainments of the higher education system in Vietnam such as the renovation of higher education
model, scale-up of education, mobilisation of investments of social strata for education,
diversification of training forms and enhancement of international cooperation, thereby affirming
meaningful contributions of the higher education system over 30 years since the renovation process
of the country (1986-2016)
Tóm tắt nội dung tài liệu: A number of achievements in higher education of Vietnam over 30 years of renovation (1986-2016)
65 A Number of Achievements in Higher Education of Vietnam over 30 Years of Renovation (1986-2016) Nguyen Thuy Quynh 1 1 Institute of History, Vietnam Academy of Social Sciences. Email: nguyenthuyquynh289@gmail.com Received on 18 February 2019. Revised on 28 February 2019. Accepted on 8 April 2019. Abstract: In the cause of comprehensive renovation of Vietnam from 1986 until now, the Party and State have implemented many guidelines, policies and measures to renovate and develop the higher education. The higher education has been gradually integrating into and moving towards the world’s conventional education model. Despite some remaining constraints and challenges, the process of renovation of tertiary education system has gained important achievements and made great contributions to the socio-economic development. This paper initially studies some attainments of the higher education system in Vietnam such as the renovation of higher education model, scale-up of education, mobilisation of investments of social strata for education, diversification of training forms and enhancement of international cooperation, thereby affirming meaningful contributions of the higher education system over 30 years since the renovation process of the country (1986-2016). Keywords: Vietnam, higher education, renovation, achievements. Subject classification: History 1. Introduction From 1986 to 2016, the higher education of Vietnam has been gradually renovated and developed. After the conference of universities in 1987, numerous guidelines, policies and measures on education renovation were implemented. The guideline on education and training renovation is one of the crucial contents in congresses and conferences. It was clearly presented in thematic conferences on education such as the 2 nd plenum of the Party Central Committee, the 7 th tenure in 1993 and the 4 th plenum of the Party Central Committee, the 8 th tenure in 1996. Notably, it is the first time in the history of Vietnamese education that the Law on Higher Education was issued in 2012 upon the promulgation of the Law on Education in 1998 and 2005. In addition, the Government Vietnam Social Sciences, No. 3 (191) - 2019 66 has also issued some decrees, circulars, directives and strategies on education and training development. The system of promulgated legal normative documents has created the legal framework for quite a comprehensive renovation in all spheres of the tertiary education of Vietnam. Over the past 30 years, the higher education has shown strong transformations and renovations in various fields such as education system structure renovation; investment source diversification; facility development enhancement; renovations in curriculum contents, teaching methods, training procedures, student recruitment modalities, examination organisation and certificate system; international cooperation expansion and so on. Besides remaining issues and limitations that need to be addressed due to subjective and objective reasons, the tertiary education has accomplished important attainments, contributing to the development of education in particular and all other aspects of the country in general. The higher education has been drastically scaled up and yielded some crucial results in the development and implementation of some renovation policies and measures. At present, historical contexts of the country and world pose to the higher education in particular and education in general many need-to-be-tackled challenges to continue to bridge gaps with the modern education and ongoing knowledge-based economic development. Therefore, it is very necessary to review the 30-year journey of tertiary education renovation, including the assessment of achieved results to continue promoting attainments and overcome remaining issues in the new renovation phase to serve practical needs of the country. Based on fundamental contents in tertiary education renovation, this research analyses some achievements of the higher education in education model renovation, education scale- up, mobilisation of investments of social strata for education and expansion of international cooperation in education. 2. Renovation of higher education model From 1986 until now, the tertiary education of Vietnam has undergone strong renovations. After the Conference of University Presidents in Nha Trang in 1987, the higher education system started its renovation process with the following measures: - Higher education transformed from the single training method which is based on the plan of giving priorities over the needs for staffing of the State and national economy to other diverse training modes in order to meet the needs for staffing of not only the State, but also economic sectors and people’s strata. The training has to go hand in glove with the demand of the labour pool. - Higher education does not just rely on the state budget but also other resources outside the state budget such as tuition fees, training contracts, contributions of economic and social organisations, self-management fees of universities, international support and so forth. - The centralised, bureaucratic and subsidised administrative management mechanisms in higher education would be reduced. Tertiary education does not just Nguyen Thuy Quynh 67 follow the centralised plan, but it also needs to match the trends and requirements of society, as while enhancing the autonomy of universities in student recruitment, training, cooperation and research. - Tertiary education would not attach to the distribution of graduates which followed the subsidised administrative mechanism. Graduates manage to find jobs by themselves in economic sectors. Job arrangement after graduation depends on the needs of employers through the regulation of the labour market. In the implementation of renovations, the elite education sector has applied concrete policies, programmes and objectives and showed fundamental changes in all spheres, especially with regard to training models. From 1993 until now, the State has issued many legal documents regulating the framework structure of education and training forms of the national education system in general and the higher education of Vietnam in particular, which were defined in a detailed and systematic manner and made responsive to international practices with the corresponding system of degrees and certificates 2 . Specifically, the framework structure of the higher education system included undergraduate, graduate and post-graduate training levels with the following specifications: - College: The duration is two to three years, which depends on the training majors, for candidates with high school or technical high school diplomas and 1.5 to 2 years for candidates with technical high school diplomas of the same training majors. - University: The duration is four to six years, which depends on the training majors, for candidates with high school or technical high school diplomas, 2,5 to 4 years for candidates with technical high school diplomas of the same majors and one to two years for candidates with college degrees of the same training majors. Training forms at college and university levels comprise regular and non-regular ones with part-time, articulation, in-service and second degree programmes as well as public and non-public schools. - Graduate training: The master training is conducted in two academic years for candidates with university degrees. The duration of doctoral training 3 is four continuous full-time years for university degree holders and three continuous full-time years for candidates with master degrees. Training forms include full-time or part-time formal programmes in accordance with regulations of each university. In special cases, the duration of doctoral level can be extended in accordance with regulations of the Ministry of Education and Training. Over the past years, the system of issued legal normative documents on education has developed a legal environment in the renovation of education management mechanism. This is the first time that Vietnam has generated the Law on Higher Education with strict regulations for this sector. Accordingly, “the education management model in the recent time has been cognitively shaped as a transformation from the management which is conducted mainly through administrative orders into the law-based one Basically, the legal framework for regulating all educational activities has been shaped and strengthened Vietnam Social Sciences, No. 3 (191) - 2019 68 step by step. Standards for the management have been continuously developed, finalised and is taking effect” [17, p.275]. A big success in this period is the system structure finalisation of the tertiary education in Vietnam for the first time in the history with the successful development of master and doctoral training levels within the country in addition to undergraduate education. With diverse and plentiful training majors in all fields, the graduate training of Vietnam has achieved certain successes. From the fact that Vietnam, previously, had to send students to foreign countries for graduate training, the country can now provide training at master and doctoral levels by itself in combination with overseas training to improve the human resource quality. If the higher education of Vietnam was influenced by and developed towards the models of France (from 1945 to 1954), the US (from 1954 to 1975 in the South) and socialist countries, especially USSR (from 1954 to the end of 1980s in the 20 th century) before the renovation process, it has integrated into and transformed towards the common model of the world’s higher education since then until now. Vietnam has renovated its higher education towards models of Western developing countries, among which the most outstanding one is the US with a close connection to three basic functions, including training, scientific research and facilitation to the socio-economic development. Education has been transformed from a part of the social welfare subsidised by the State with the complete reliance on a centralised, bureaucratic and subsidised model into the general cause of the State and society based on a decentralised, democratic and modernised model. Gaining ground on that, the higher education is gradually exposing and adapting to requirements of the market mechanism at different levels and recognised as a commercial service area. Accordingly, “the role of education in society has been changed from “a product of the egalitarianism” to “a normal investment area” [1, p.89]. On the other hand, the development of a learning society model is paid special interest to mobilise resources for development, as while meeting requirements of the multi-sectoral market economy development and needs for developing human resources, especially high-quality one with creativity and lifelong learning ability. In short, over 30 years after the renovation process, the higher education has step by step renovated its model to align with requirements of the country and current trends. Accordingly, the model developed by Vietnam has many similarities and dissimilarities with the common pattern of the world. The identification of directions and renovations for the development model is considered a success of the Vietnamese higher education in the context of global changes because the problem is not only clarifying how many years the education has been lagged behind but also marking out the orientation to overcome such backwardness. This plays an important role in the renovation process of education and is the fundamental condition for the renovation and development of the Vietnamese higher education. Nguyen Thuy Quynh 69 3. Development of training scale Over 30 years after the renovation process, the higher education has achieved great attainments in the expansion and development of training scale. The network of universities and colleges has been developed and satisfied better the learning demand of society. Colleges and universities are located in big residential areas, regions and provinces. Besides big provinces and centrally-run cities such as Hanoi, Ho Chi Minh City, Red River Delta and southeastern region, the State has prioritised the additional establishment of universities and colleges in difficult regions such as northwestern region, Central Highlands and Mekong Delta (Table 1). For the number of universities and colleges, if there were only 96 universities and colleges throughout the country in 1986, this figure increased to 110 universities with two national universities, three regional universities, many other specialised, open and people-funded universities and 43 colleges [10] in 1997. In 2006, the number of universities and colleges were 299 with 253 public ones and 46 non-public ones [9], [10], [11]. In 2014, the whole country had 436 universities and colleges (219 universities and 217 colleges), which was 4.5 times higher than in 1986 and included 347 public ones and 89 non-public ones. The number of universities increased to 235 with 170 public ones and 65 non-public ones in 2016 [17]. Despite many hardships, the facilities and equipment of universities and colleges have been gradually standardized and modernised. The system of lecture halls, libraries, internet networks, e-libraries, multi-media teaching instruments and learning resources is very diverse and plentiful, which will facilitate the study and research of students and lecturers. With regard to the number of teachers and students in universities and colleges, there were 19,200 teachers and 91,200 students in long-term programmes in 1986. These figures increased to 23,500 and 236,300 respectively in 1996. In 2006, 20 years after the renovation process, the number of teachers doubled (53,400) with 24,325 teachers of graduate level, 28,460 teachers of undergraduate level and 579 teachers of other levels. Meanwhile, the number of students in the same year increased by 16 times to 1,666,200 with 230,000 students successfully getting their bachelor degrees [9], [10], [11]. By 2015, the number of teachers in universities and colleges had been 93,500, including 76,100 teachers of public universities and colleges (81.4%) and 17,400 teachers of non-public ones. The number of students in universities and colleges of the same year was 2,118,500 with 353,600 students successfully getting their bachelor degrees; (see mor ... project on technical and vocational training (ADB, NDF and AFD as co-sponsors), the higher education policy development programme and scholarships of Australia, Japan, the U.S and so on for Vietnamese undergraduates and graduates. In 2014, there were another 25 foreign investment projects just for higher education with the total funding of USD 77.5 million [19]. According to statistics of the Foreign Investment Agency, by 20 May, 2015, there had been 213 FDI projects in education throughout the country with the total registered funding of USD 822 million [8]. In addition, many international cooperation models with foreign partners have been efficiently implemented. New universities have been developed such as the Vietnam-Germany University, Vietnam- Russia University of Technology, British University in Vietnam, Vietnam-Japan University, American University in Vietnam and others. Togerther with the renovation in student recruitment and standardisation of training curricula, the Ministry of Education and Training has also focused on directing leading schools to pilot the training programmes based on advanced programmes and course books of some countries in accordance with the stewardship of the Prime Minister from 2004. Many universities have trained their students with international Vietnam Social Sciences, No. 3 (191) - 2019 76 advanced programmes, some of which are directly taught in English by professors from prestigious universities in the world. The cooperation models have made important contribtuions to promote the integration of the Vietnamese higher education into advanced ones in the world. Many universities have even launched partnership programmes with foreign establishments. By 2012, 163 partnership training programmes with foreign establishments at 58 training facilities had been approved all over the country. These programmes focus on economic, financial and banking sectors with training levels ranging up to that of the master’s degree. Some universities and colleges invested with foreign capitals have been established and put into operation in Vietnam. Vietnam- Germany University and University of Science and Technology of Hanoi (or Vietnam-France University) were founded as the results of international cooperation models with special organisation and operation mechanisms to attract foreign financial support. In the assignment of students to study in foreign countries, many scholarship projects and programmes funded by the state budget have yielded positive results 7 . In addition, by effective policies, Vietnamese students studying in foreign countries are continuously increasing. The reception of foreign students enrolled in Vietnamese training facilities is proceeded by Agreements, scholarships, bilateral cooperations and self-funding with countries having the capacity of thousands of foreign students such as Laos, Cambodia, the Republic of Korea, the Democratic Republic of Korea, China, Mongolia, Russia, France, Poland, etc. Foreign students are granted scholarships by the State of Vietnam in accordance with Agreements signed between the Socialist Republic of Vietnam and their countries. Particularly, the trend of studying abroad of Vietnamese students is ever-increasing at the tertiary education level [5, p.53]. The number of students sent abroad for training in 1986 was 4,188 people, including 273 PhD students and 725 undergraduates [10, p.299]. By 2013, the Ministry of Education and Training had managed and granted scholarships to nearly 6,000 Vietnamese people to study in nearly 40 countries in the world, nearly 4,000 foreigners studying in Vietnam and more than 100 experts teaching in African and Asian countries [2, p.106]. According to statistics of the Department of Training with Foreign Countries under the Ministry of Education and Training, by 2016, more than 10,000 foreign students, most of whom come from Laos and Cambodia, were studying in Vietnam and nearly 110,000 Vietnamese citizens, increasing by 5% in comparison to 2013 [3], were studying in foreign countries (mainly the US, Australia and Japan). Together with scholarships from the government, it is estimated that about 20,000 students are studying abroad by their own budgets and this figure increases every year. The number of students studying in the US and Western European countries is ever-rising. By 2020, the Ministry of Education and Training will plan to send about 2,500 lecturers for training in the US, 1,000 in the U.K, 700 in France and 1,000 in Germany and other countries [14], [4, p.69]. In short, international cooperation activities in education have ensured the requirements of bilateral and multilateral Nguyen Thuy Quynh 77 cooperation in a better manner, contributing to the development of education and improvement of the position and role of Vietnam in the region and world. These cooperation models have made crucial contributions to the integration of the Vietnamese higher education into advanced ones in the world. Not only public schools, but also people-funded ones have initially and actively expanded their international cooperation relationships. Through the implementation of projects, agreements and others, the Vietnamese education has acquired experience in education from countries in the world, as while enhancing resources for the domestic education with assisting projects and foreign investments. This has contributed to the accomplishment of important objectives of the sector such as improving the capacity to formulate education development policies and strategies, strengthening the facilities for schools, developing and renovating the teaching contents and frameworks and fostering the professional knowledge for teachers as well as research and management staff. 6. Conclusion Over 30 years (1986-2016), the Vietnamese education has increasingly renovated to find the right direction in line with the current trend and new context of the country. In the renovation process, in spite of many difficulties, weaknesses and limitations, the higher education has gained some important achievements, contributing to the development of the education in particular and the country in general such as the renovation of higher education models, expansion of training scale, mobilisation of investments of social strata for education, diversification of training forms and enhancement of international cooperation and integration. Gained achievements have affirmed the crucial role and meaningful contributions of the higher education sector in the structure of the national education system, improvement of the people’s intellect, training of human resources, especially high-quality one and promotion of talents for the country. At the same time, attainments in higher education have also made important contributions to the cause of socio-economic development of the country over 30 years of renovation. At present, education in general and higher education in particular are facing major challenges in the trends of globalisation and international integration. Therefore, attained achievements are important foundations and precious lessons for the cause of renovating and developing higher education in the years to come. Notes 1 The paper was published in Vietnamese in: Nghiên cứu Đông Nam Á, số 9, 2018. Translated by Vu Xuan Nuoc. 2 These documents include: Decree No.90/CP dated 24 November, 1993 by the Government regulating the framework structure of the national education system and the system of degrees and certificates on education and training of the Socialist Republic of Vietnam, the Law on Education of 1998, the Law on Education of 2005, the Law on Education (revised) of 2009 and especially the Law on Higher Education of 2012 and the Law on Higher Education (amended and supplemented) of 2014. 3 The training with two levels (Candidate, or Associate Doctor, and Doctor) was replaced by the Vietnam Social Sciences, No. 3 (191) - 2019 78 training with one level (Doctor) in 1993. In 2000, at the discretion of the Prime Minister, the Ministry of Education and Training issued the decision on unifying the academic titles of “Doctor” and “Associate Doctor”. 4 Resolution No. 29-NQ/TW dated 4 November, 2013 of the 8 th plenum of the Party Central Committee, the 11 th tenure on fundamental and comprehensive innovation in education, serving industrialisation and modernisation in a socialist-oriented market economy during international integration. 5 The contributions to the development of important legal documents such as the Law on Education, the Law on Higher Education, the Law on Teachers, the Draft Education Development Strategy in the periods of 2001-2010 and 2011-2020, regulations on organisation, management and charter of universities and policies on tuition fee, student recruitment target and entrance examination and so on. 6 Schools with foreign investments mainly focus on the higher education sector due to the high demand of people and appropriate levels of investment. In 2007, there were nearly 70 facilities for foreign language training and professional knowledge development partly invested by foreign capitals and two universities of 100% foreign investments (RMIT University (Australia) and Dresden Training Centre (Germany) in Hanoi University of Science and Technology). By 2010, five universities of 100% foreign investments had been established in Vietnam. 7 Outstanding projects include Project 322/356 on training scientific and technical officials in foreign countries with the state budget, Project 165 on training leaders and managers in foreign countries with the state budget, Project 911 on training lecturers of doctoral level for universities and colleges in the period of 2010-2020, the Project “Training Officials in Foreign Countries with the State Budget in the Period of 2013-2020” (Project 599), Training programme for legal experts of the Ministry of Justice and so on. References [1] Alexandre Dormeier Freire (2010), “Hai mươi năm đổi mới ngành giáo dục: giữa những thành công và bất ổn”, Kỷ yếu Hội thảo quốc tế Việt Nam học lần thứ ba: Việt Nam: Hội nhập và phát triển, t.6, Nxb Đại học Quốc gia Hà Nội. [Alexandre Dormeier Freire (2010), “20 Years of Renovation in Education: Between Success and Instability”, Proceedings of 3rd International Workshop on Vietnamese Studies: Vietnam: Integration and Development, Vol. 6, Vietnam National University Press]. [2] Bộ Giáo dục và Đào tạo (2013), Giáo dục Việt Nam đầu thế kỷ XXI, Nxb Giáo dục Việt Nam, Hà Nội. [Ministry of Education and Training (2013), Vietnamese Education in 21 st Century, Vietnam Education Publishing House, Hanoi]. [3] Phạm Đức Chính, Nguyễn Tiến Dũng (2014), Giáo dục đại học Việt Nam góc nhìn từ lý thuyết kinh tế - tài chính hiện đại, Nxb Chính trị Quốc gia - Sự thật, Hà Nội. [Pham Duc Chinh, Nguyen Tien Dung (2014), Vietnamese Higher Education from Perspective of Modern Economic and Financial Theories, National Political Publishing House, Hanoi]. [4] Nguyễn Hồng Chí (2013), "Dòng chảy của du học sinh Việt Nam”, Kỷ yếu Hội thảo quốc tế lần thứ tư - Việt Nam trên đường hội nhập và phát triển bền vững, Nxb Khoa học xã hội, Hà Nội. [Nguyen Hong Chi (2013), "Flows of Vietnamese Students Abroad”, Proceedings of 4 th International Workshop - Vietnam on Path of Integration and Sustainable Development, Social Sciences Publishing House, Hanoi]. [5] Vũ Ngọc Hải, Đặng Bá Lãm, Trần Khánh Đức (đồng chủ biên) (2007), Giáo dục Việt Nam đổi mới và phát triển hiện đại hóa, Nxb Giáo dục, Hà Nội. [Vu Ngoc Hai, Dang Ba Lam, Tran Khanh Duc (co-chief authors) (2007), Vietnamese Nguyen Thuy Quynh 79 Education - Renovation, Development and Modernisation, Vietnam Education Publishing House, Hanoi]. [6] Nguyễn Quang Kính (2005), Giáo dục Việt Nam 1945-2005, Nxb Giáo dục, Hà Nội. [Nguyen Quang Kinh (2005), Vietnamese Education in 1945-2005, Vietnam Education Publishing House, Hanoi]. [7] Nguyễn Minh Phương (2012), Đẩy mạnh xã hội hóa giáo dục, y tế ở Việt Nam, Nxb Chính trị Quốc gia - Sự thật, Hà Nội. [Nguyen Minh Phuong (2012), Boosting Investments of Social Strata in Education and Health in Vietnam, National Political Publishing House, Hanoi]. [8] Tổng cục Thống kê (1988), Niên giám thống kê năm 1986, Nxb Thống kê, Hà Nội. [General Statistics Office (1988), Statistical Yearbook of 1986, Statistical Publishing House, Hanoi]. [9] Tổng cục Thống kê (2002), Số liệu thống kê năm 2001, Nxb Thống kê, Hà Nội [General Statistics Office (2002), Statistics of 2001, Statistical Publishing House, Hanoi]. [10] Tổng cục Thống kê (2006), Việt Nam 20 năm đổi mới và phát triển 1986-2005, Nxb Thống kê, Hà Nội. [General Statistics Office (2006), Vietnam - 20 Years of Renovation and Development (1986-2005), Statistical Publishing House, Hanoi]. [11] Tổng cục Thống kê (2007), Số liệu thống kê năm 2006, Nxb Thống kê, Hà Nội [General Statistics Office (2007), Statistics of 2006, Statistical Publishing House, Hanoi]. [12] Trung tâm Lưu trữ Quốc gia III, Phông Văn phòng Chính phủ, Hồ sơ số 2622, Hà Nội. [National Archives Centre No. 3, Folder on the Office of the Government, Dossier No. 2622, Hanoi]. [13] Hien Tran (2009), Transformation of Higher Education in Vietnam after Doimoi: A Story of “Dualism”, St. John’s University, New York. [14] Hải Hà, 90% học sinh Việt Nam du học tự túc, sinh-viet-nam-du-hoc-tu-tuc_t114c8n84311, truy cập ngày 8 tháng 5 năm 2016. [Hai Ha, 90% of Vietnamese Students Study Abroad by Their Own Budgets, hoi/giao-duc/90-hoc-sinh-viet-nam-du-hoc-tu- tuc_t114c8n84311, retrieved on 8 May, 2016]. [15] Phương Ly, Thúc đẩy đầu tư trực tiếp nước ngoài vào lĩnh vực giáo dục - đào tạo, aydaututructiep-nd-17038.html, truy cập ngày 8 tháng 5 năm 2016. [Phuong Ly, Promoting Foreign Direct Investments in Education and Training, Pages/thucdaydaututructiep-nd-17038.html, retrieved on 8 May 2016]. [16] Xuân Trung, Bộ Giáo dục xác định 3 nhiệm vụ trọng tâm năm học 2015-2016, duc-xac-dinh-3-nhiem-vu-trong-tam-nam- hoc-20152016-post162731.gd, truy cập ngày 15 tháng 6 năm 2016 [Xuan Trung, Ministry of Education and Training Set out Three Leading Tasks in Academic Year of 2015- 2016, Giao-duc-xac-dinh-3-nhiem-vu-trong-tam- nam-hoc-20152016-post162731.gd, retrieved on 15 June 2016]. [17] https://www.gso.gov.vn/default.aspx?tabid=722, retrieved on 15 June, 2016 [18] nid=40&y=2008&m=2&d=21, retrieved on 8 May 2016 [19] https://www.gso.gov.vn/default.aspx?tabid=716, retrieved on 15 June 2016
File đính kèm:
- a_number_of_achievements_in_higher_education_of_vietnam_over.pdf